Transformer Differential Protection Setting Calculations

Transformer differential protection is a key scheme used to protect transformers from internal faults, such as short circuits, phase-to-phase faults, and winding faults. It functions by comparing the currents entering and leaving the transformer. If the difference between these currents exceeds a certain threshold, it indicates a potential fault within the transformer zone. Setting calculations for transformer differential protection must be precise to ensure sensitivity to faults while minimizing the risk of false trips due to normal operating conditions, like inrush currents and CT (current transformer) mismatches.

Key Principles of Transformer Differential Protection

The basic principle of differential protection is that under normal operating conditions, the current entering the transformer should equal the current leaving, accounting for any turn ratio. However, during a fault within the transformer, the difference (or “differential current”) will exceed the preset threshold, triggering the protection relay to isolate the transformer.

1. Differential Current (Idiff): This is the difference between primary and secondary currents, corrected for turns ratio and CT ratio.
2. Stabilizing Current (Istab): Also called restraining current, it’s the average of the primary and secondary currents. It helps to stabilize the protection against external faults and transient phenomena like inrush currents.

Steps in Setting Calculations for Transformer Differential Protection

1. Determine CT Ratios and Turns Ratio Compensation

• CT Ratio Matching: Current transformers (CTs) on each side of the transformer must be appropriately selected to ensure that the differential relay can measure equivalent currents.
• Turns Ratio Compensation: Transformers have different voltage levels on each side, so the CT secondary currents are scaled according to the transformer’s turns ratio to equalize the currents for comparison by the relay.

$$I_{\text{primary}} \times \text{CT primary ratio} = I_{\text{secondary}} \times \text{CT secondary ratio}$$

2. Calculate the Differential Current Setting (Idiff)

• Pickup Setting (Idiff min): The minimum differential current setting should be high enough to avoid false tripping due to measurement errors and normal operating conditions but sensitive enough to detect faults. A common value for the pickup setting is around 0.2 to 0.3 per unit (pu) of the transformer-rated current.

For example, for a transformer rated at 100 MVA, with a primary voltage of 132 kV, calculate the rated current as follows:

$$I_{\text{rated primary}} = \frac{\text{Transformer Rating}}{\sqrt{3} \times V_{\text{primary}}}$$

 

Applying this rated current in per unit terms helps define the differential current setting.

3. Restraint Current Calculation (Istab)

• Restraint Current Setting: Restraint current (Istab) is the mean or the greater of the primary and secondary currents (scaled to per unit), often used to stabilize the differential relay. This restraint setting helps the relay ignore inrush currents and external faults. A common setting for restraint current is around 0.3 to 0.5 pu.

The restraint current (Istab) is typically defined as:

$$I_{\text{stab}} = \frac{|I_{\text{primary}}| + |I_{\text{secondary}}|}{2}$$

or, alternatively, as the maximum of primary and secondary currents.

4. Slope Settings for Percentage Differential Protection

• Dual-Slope Characteristics: Modern differential relays use a dual-slope characteristic to enhance stability under external fault conditions and high through-currents. These slopes are defined as percentages, such as Slope 1 (lower threshold) and Slope 2 (higher threshold).
• Slope 1: Generally set between 10% and 40%, depending on CT accuracy and transformer inrush characteristics. This lower slope allows sensitivity to low-level internal faults while maintaining stability during inrush.
• Slope 2: Often set around 60% to 80%. This steeper slope is used to handle high through-currents during external faults, allowing the relay to differentiate between external and internal faults effectively.

The differential relay’s operating condition can be determined by comparing Idiff against the restraining current and applying the slope characteristic as:

$$\text{Operate if } I_{\text{diff}} > (\text{Slope} \times I_{\text{stab}})$$

5. Inrush and Overexcitation Blocking

• Second-Harmonic Restraint for Inrush: Transformer energization can cause high inrush currents, which are rich in the second harmonic. Relays often incorporate a second-harmonic restraint to prevent tripping during inrush conditions. Typical settings block the relay when the second harmonic component is around 15-20% of the fundamental frequency component.
• Fifth-Harmonic Restraint for Overexcitation: Overexcitation of the transformer (often due to overvoltage) causes fifth harmonics. The fifth-harmonic restraint setting typically blocks tripping when fifth harmonic exceeds around 25-30% of the fundamental component.

6. Testing and Verification

After setting calculations are completed, testing and verification are essential to ensure the differential protection scheme operates correctly under real-world conditions. Testing involves:

• Primary and Secondary Injection Testing: To verify CT ratios and relay response.
• Simulating Fault Conditions: Simulating internal and external faults to observe relay behavior and confirm the set thresholds.

Summary of Typical Setting Ranges

Setting	Typical Range
Pickup Setting (Idiff min)	0.2 – 0.3 pu
Restraint Current (Istab)	0.3 – 0.5 pu
Slope 1	10% – 40%
Slope 2	60% – 80%
Second Harmonic Inrush Restraint	15% – 20%
Fifth Harmonic Overexcitation Restraint	25% – 30%

Conclusion

Setting calculations for transformer differential protection involve careful consideration of transformer characteristics, current transformer ratios, and harmonics to provide sensitivity to internal faults while avoiding false trips. By correctly applying differential and restraint settings, inrush and overexcitation blocking, and thorough testing, differential protection effectively safeguards transformers and ensures system reliability.

You have to wait 10 seconds.

Download Timer